1. Nov 4, 2012 3:01pm

    Archaeologists banned from referring to ancient humanoids as “hobbits”

    Homo floresiensis likely stood about 3’6”, making this prehistoric human roughly the average height of one of J.R.R. Tolkien’s Hobbits. For years, Flores Man has been referred to by the nickname “hobbit,” contributing to the species’ popularity. But one company that owns film rights in The Hobbit has decided that the archaeologists who discovered Homo floresiensis cannot refer to the ancient human by that name.

    The Guardian reports that Dr Brent Alloway, associate professor at Victoria University, is planning a free lecture on Homo floresiensis by Mike Morwood and Thomas Sutikna, two of the archaeologists who discovered the species. But when Alloway approached the Saul Zaentz Company/Middle-earth Enterprises, which owns rights in the film, for permission to title the lecture, “The Other Hobbit,” their lawyer responded that ”it is not possible for our client to allow generic use of the trade mark HOBBIT.” The Tolkien Estate, which owns registered trademarks on the word “Hobbit” in several companies, was not approached.

    On the one hand, I can see a company that has a trademark interest in the word “hobbit” worrying about that word becoming generic. And Alloway acknowledges that he organized the lecture specifically to coincide with the release of The Hobbit film and capitalize on the name. But Alloway and his fellow scientists are clearly using the word in a different market—scientific, rather than storytelling—and the very fact that they call it “The Other Hobbit” acknowledges Tolkien’s invention of the word.

    But regardless of whether the Saul Zaentz Company is legally obligated to protect its trademark interest in the word “hobbit,” it strikes me that this conflict could have had a very simple resolution. The company could have licensed the use of the word to the lecture organizers for a nominal fee. Even without the company’s blessing, however, Homo floresiensis remains a “hobbit” in much scientific literature—and in our hearts.

    Photo: Cast of Homo floresiensis compared to a microcephalic skull by Avandergeer from Wikimedia Commons.

    Hobbit banned as title of lecture on prehistoric ‘hobbit’ [The Guardian via reddit]

  1. quietlonersoul reblogged this from io9updates
  2. citizenoftheworld87 reblogged this from io9updates and added:
  3. heinricho reblogged this from io9updates and added:
    No hobbitses for you!
  4. galliumhydroxide reblogged this from asexualmagneto
  5. iceageiscoming reblogged this from microlina and added:
    Gente sveglia
  6. microlina reblogged this from thec8h10n4o2
  7. thec8h10n4o2 reblogged this from plurdledgabbleblotchits and added:
    Gli scienziati funzionano così, una parola spesa male e sei finito. Se volete morire professionalmente vi basta...
  8. plurdledgabbleblotchits reblogged this from fuckyeahilike
  9. bactaqueen reblogged this from fuckyeahilike and added:
    So rather than allow or even license the use of the word in order to draw attention to human evolution and scientific...
  10. fuckyeahilike reblogged this from ladytr0n
  11. the-smyths reblogged this from danglingthpider
  12. kayllock reblogged this from spookgosh
  13. braile85 reblogged this from danglingthpider
  14. violentsarcasm reblogged this from danglingthpider
  15. fillorykid reblogged this from spookgosh
  16. yesshesthetallone reblogged this from thranduskul
  17. m1ssc0mmun1cat10n reblogged this from spookgosh and added:
    I’ve been using the term ‘hobbit’ generically as a description for people who kinda look like hobbits. For aaages. As...
  18. willdangergraham reblogged this from internhamish
  19. ambalynne reblogged this from spookgosh
  20. spookgosh reblogged this from asexualmagneto
  21. internhamish reblogged this from danglingthpider
  22. insanely-docile reblogged this from danglingthpider
  23. greenassin reblogged this from thranduskul
  24. asexualmagneto reblogged this from danglingthpider
  25. thranduskul reblogged this from danglingthpider and added:
  26. incenseandindianfood reblogged this from danglingthpider
  27. danglingthpider reblogged this from sherlockian-of-the-shire
  28. hobbitparty reblogged this from sherlockian-of-the-shire
  29. sherlockian-of-the-shire reblogged this from the---cat--is--called--hamish
  30. the---cat--is--called--hamish reblogged this from io9updates